Fleet of commercial trucks lined up in a parking lot

The Benefits of a Low FMCSA Safety Score for Fleet Operations and Drivers

Safety should always be a priority for your fleet, but do you know how to measure it? The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) plays a crucial role in ensuring the safety and efficiency of fleet operations. One of the key metrics used by the FMCSA to evaluate carriers’ safety performance is the FMCSA safety score.

The FMCSA safety score is a critical measure of safety compliance for commercial drivers and a mark of your commitment to fleet safety. A low FMCSA safety score shows that you prioritize safety for your fleet and can also be incredibly beneficial for both your fleet operations and drivers. 

Read on to learn more about the benefits of having a low FMCSA safety score and the steps you can take to improve your score over time. By understanding these benefits, transportation management and drivers can work together to improve safety standards, mitigate risks, and enhance overall performance.

The FMCSA Safety Score Explained

The FMCSA safety score is a crucial metric used by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to evaluate the safety performance of carriers in the trucking and transportation industry. It is a comprehensive assessment that takes into account various factors related to safety and compliance. The score is based on the carrier’s performance in areas such as crash involvement, driver violations, vehicle maintenance, and adherence to federal regulations.

A carrier’s safety score is derived from data collected through the FMCSA’s Safety Measurement System (SMS), which analyzes carrier performance based on inspections, crash reports, and other relevant data sources. The system assigns a score to carriers, representing their safety record and compliance with safety regulations.

The score is often presented in the form of a percentile ranking, ranging from 0 to 100. A higher score indicates a poorer safety record and a higher likelihood of safety violations. Conversely, a lower score indicates a better fleet safety performance and a stronger commitment to compliance.

The FMCSA Safety Score serves as an important tool for transportation management, carriers, and drivers. It helps identify areas that require improvement, enables benchmarking against industry standards, and provides a basis for evaluating carrier safety when establishing partnerships or contracts. By monitoring and striving for a low FMCSA Safety Score, fleet operations and drivers can prioritize safety, reduce risks, and enhance their overall performance.

How do BASIC Scores Affect FMCSA Safety Score? 

A company’s BASIC (Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories) scores are a component of the FMCSA safety score. The FMCSA uses the Safety Measurement System (SMS) to calculate BASIC scores, which are specific categories that assess different aspects of carrier safety records. There are seven BASIC categories:

    1. Unsafe Driving: Evaluates driver behaviors such as speeding, reckless driving, and improper lane changes.
    2. Hours of Service Compliance: Assesses compliance with regulations regarding drivers’ working hours and rest periods.
    3. Driver Fitness: Focuses on driver qualifications, including medical certifications, licenses, and training.
    4. Controlled Substances/Alcohol: Monitors compliance with regulations related to drug and alcohol use by drivers.
    5. Vehicle Maintenance: Evaluates the carrier’s adherence to vehicle maintenance and inspection requirements.
    6. Hazardous Materials Compliance: Assesses compliance with regulations for the safe transportation of hazardous materials.
    7. Crash Indicator: Takes into account the carrier’s crash involvement and frequency.

Each BASIC category is assigned a score based on the carrier’s performance in that particular area. These scores are then used to calculate the overall FMCSA Safety Score for the carrier. The BASIC scores contribute to the carrier’s percentile ranking, indicating their relative safety performance compared to other carriers.

A company’s BASIC scores provide specific insights into areas where safety performance may be lacking, allowing carriers to identify and address potential issues. By improving their performance in each BASIC category, carriers can ultimately work towards achieving a low FMCSA safety score, demonstrating a strong commitment to safety and compliance.


How to Find Your FMCSA Score

Fleets can check their CSA safety scores and other safety-related information through the FMCSA’s Safety Measurement System (SMS) website. Here are the steps to access and review the FMCSA safety scores:

      • Visit the FMCSA SMS website: Go to the FMCSA’s official SMS website at https://ai.fmcsa.dot.gov/SMS/.
      • Enter the company’s USDOT number: On the SMS homepage, enter the USDOT number of the fleet/company you want to check. The USDOT number uniquely identifies the carrier and is required to access the safety scores.
      • Review the safety scores: Once you enter the USDOT number and click on the “GO” button, the system will retrieve safety-related data for the carrier. This includes the carrier’s BASIC scores (Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories) in each of the seven categories, as well as their overall FMCSA Safety Score. The scores are typically presented in the form of percentile rankings.
      • Understand the scores: Take the time to review and understand the significance of each BASIC score and how it contributes to the overall safety score. This will help identify areas that may require improvement and guide efforts to enhance safety and compliance.

It’s important to note that accessing the FMCSA Safety Scores through the SMS website requires a valid USDOT number. Carriers and fleet operators should ensure they have the necessary information and authorization to review their scores. Additionally, the FMCSA regularly updates the SMS data, so it is advisable to check the scores periodically for the most up-to-date information.

Benefits of Having a Low FMCSA Safety Score

By understanding the benefits of maintaining a low safety score, transportation managers and drivers can work together to improve safety standards, mitigate risks, and enhance overall performance. 

There are a multitude of benefits to a low safety score but here are just a few to strive for: 

Enhanced Safety Culture

Maintaining a low FMCSA Safety Score signifies a strong commitment to safety within fleet operations. It demonstrates that carriers prioritize compliance, driver training, and fleet safety protocols. This commitment fosters a safety-conscious culture, where everyone, from management to drivers, actively participates in creating a safe work environment. By emphasizing safety, fleet operations can reduce accidents, injuries, and fatalities, leading to a more secure and productive workplace.

Improved Driver Satisfaction and Well-being

A low FMCSA Safety Score directly benefits truck drivers by prioritizing their well-being, driver fitness, and job satisfaction. With a focus on safety, carriers invest in driver training programs, regular vehicle maintenance, and compliance with regulations. Drivers feel more secure and supported when working for carriers with a low safety score, knowing that their employer prioritizes their safety on the road. This can lead to increased job satisfaction, reduced turnover rates, and improved driver retention for fleet operations.

Cost Reduction and Resource Optimization 

Maintaining a low FMCSA Safety Score can result in significant cost reductions for fleet operations. A strong safety record indicates fewer accidents, violations, and associated costs. Carriers with a low safety score are less likely to incur fines, penalties, or legal fees resulting from non-compliance. Moreover, a focus on safety leads to better fuel efficiency, reduced vehicle maintenance expenses, and lower insurance premiums. By optimizing resources and minimizing risks, fleet operations can improve their financial performance and competitiveness.

Enhanced Business Opportunities 

A low FMCSA Safety Score opens doors to new business opportunities for fleet operations. Shippers and clients prioritize carriers with a strong safety record, as it reflects their commitment to reliable and secure transportation services. A low safety score provides a competitive edge when bidding for contracts and securing partnerships. By showcasing a commitment to safety and compliance, fleet operations can attract reputable clients, expand their customer base, and enhance their market position.

Reduced Regulatory Scrutiny 

Carriers with low safety and CSA scores experience reduced regulatory scrutiny from the FMCSA. This means fewer compliance audits, inspections, and investigations, allowing fleet operations to focus on their core activities. With a low safety score, carriers are less likely to be subjected to frequent interruptions or disruptions caused by regulatory interventions such as roadside inspections. Also, it is important to note services like weigh station bypass partner, Drivewyze, specifically relies on a motor carrier’s ISS and safety score when granting interstate bypasses.  This enables fleet operations to allocate resources more efficiently and maintain consistent operational performance.

Tips for Improving Your FMCSA Score

If you’ve found yourself with a high FMCSA safety score it’s not too late to start improving! 

To improve your score, it is essential to prioritize several key strategies. First, creating a culture of safety within the organization is paramount. This involves promoting safety as a core value, encouraging open communication about safety concerns, and providing ongoing training and education to all employees. Additionally, better fleet management to minimize HOS violations can be achieved by partnering with a supportive telematics provider. Making a change to your fleet management provider can help better manage driver compliance, implement regular vehicle maintenance programs, utilize ELD and dash camera technology to monitor driver behavior and performance, and optimize routing and scheduling to minimize driver fatigue. 

Driver training holds significant importance as well. By providing comprehensive and regular training programs with a robust safety education program, trucking companies can equip drivers with the knowledge and skills needed to navigate potential hazards, understand and comply with regulations, and effectively respond to unexpected situations on the road. Overall, a proactive approach to safety, encompassing culture, fleet management, and driver training, can greatly contribute to improving the FMCSA safety score and promoting a safer and more efficient trucking industry.

Maintaining a low FMCSA safety score brings numerous benefits to fleet operations and professional truck drivers. It fosters an enhanced safety culture, improves driver satisfaction, reduces costs, opens new business opportunities, and reduces regulatory scrutiny. 

By prioritizing safety and compliance, fleet administrators can protect their drivers, minimize risks, and optimize overall fleet performance. Together, fleet operations, drivers, and transportation management can work towards achieving and maintaining a low FMCSA safety score, contributing to a safer and more efficient trucking industry.

Help your fleet obtain a low FMCSA safety score!

Konexial provides superb technology to the transportation industry through the PaaS (platform as a service) model featuring fleet management, video, and safety management, asset tracking, fuel savings programs, and more.

3214 Tazewell Pike Suite 101 Knoxville, TN 37918

865-888-MY20 (6920)